Book Review: Heart Murmurs by R.R. Smythe

September 14, 2015 Blog, Book Reviews 0

Book Review: Heart Murmurs by R.R. SmytheHeart Murmurs by R.R. Smythe
Published by CreateSpace on March 20th 2013
Genres: Romance, Young Adult
Pages: 210
Source: AudioBook Reviewer
One StarOne StarHalf a Star

Mia Templeton is dying. Or was dying. After receiving a heart transplant, she overhears her donor was a murdered girl of the same age.

Whispers invade her head, she develops tastes for foods she once hated, and dreams so vivid, she feels they’re someone else’s memories.

Once a quiet doormat, she’s now flippant and confident. And her longing for the new boy at school is borderline obsessive.


My thoughts

While I did not dislike this book, the synopsis is not quite enough to go on. I was expecting what I read in the synopsis, to read about a girl that had some of the inclinations of the person that gave her a heart. Sadly, it’s a lot more than that. A lot more.

What I did like was the personalities in the story. The characters do seem to jump off of the page. Or out of the headphones since I listened to this one. They are all in high school so it was pretty easy to remember and sympathize with the main character. She’s a mouse and people are used to walking all over her; at least until her operation. But her personality did not do a complete flip. In most cases she spoke up for herself and that was odd, but it was the voices that she was starting to hear that really started to add something to the story.

Insert Morgan, the hot new kid that all the girls are drooling over! Mia isn’t shy about trying to find out who he is. It’s almost like she feels compelled to be with him but can’t explain why. This portion was a little odd too but young love always is so whatever, I was willing to go with the flow. The strangeness is when Morgan and Mia actually meet and all kinds of weird, or weirder stuff starts happening.

This is the part where I started getting lost. Ever see Project Runway? It’s an obsession of mine. Tim Gunn tells the participating designers to reel in their designs if they are getting too crazy and I feel like that’s what needs to be done here. First we have the heart transplant, the reader has to understand where Mia was compared to is currently, get to know all her friends, her obsession with Morgan, her job and her obsession with Austin (although I get that), and on top of that there is this whole entire caste system that is thrown in!

I’m not saying I did not like it but wow, that is a lot to keep up with. The further I got into listening to the book, the more happens too! It is a really strange mixture of Alice in Wonderland meets The Hunger Games with a bit of Twilight in there because Mia cannot live without Morgan. Ugh… I hate insta love.

There’s an entire portion that is all about Edgar Allan Poe. I love his writing. LOVE! Like I would stalk him if he were alive today, maybe not literally but still, I would think about it. This is just another added portion to ALL of the above. Why is this even in here? I get the literary part of it but there has to be a moment when someone like Tim Gunn says, can we please edit back some of this script, please?

So, really… it’s an okay book but there’s a lot in this. Like, a LOT. I wouldn’t mind the story if it were spread out and there were some clues as to why things happen the way they do at the end and why people are making her fight, and who are these people anyway!? It’s just too much.

Full audio review can be found at

The Author



About R.R. Smythe

Born and raised in western Pennsylvania, R R Smythe is the daughter of two teachers. Her writing reflects her passions: science, history and love—not necessarily in that order. In real life, the geek gene runs strong in her family, as does the Asperger’s syndrome. Her writing reflects her experience as a pediatric therapist and her interactions with society’s downtrodden. In fiction, she’s a strong believer in underdogs and happily-ever-afters. She also writes non-fiction and lectures on the subjects of autism and sensory integration and is a medical contributor to online journal The Age of Autism.

She also writes under the pseudonym Brynn Chapman .

One StarOne StarHalf a Star
Comments are closed.